Tag Archives: love story

This Is How It Ends – Kathleen MacMahon – 7/10

“A human anachronism, sitting there fossilising in the window while the rest of the world carried on without him.”

Kathleen MacMahon’s debut novel hit the headlines for receiving a £600,000 advance from Sphere, unheard of in today’s difficult publishing economy. A huge stake on a novel about an American man who escapes the 2008 election by travelling to Ireland to seek out his family roots. His roots aren’t so keen to be dug up though, with difficulties of their own including broken wrists, recent miscarriages and a rescue dog named Lola.

I can’t fault this novel, and yet I’m struggling to be hugely enthusiastic about it either.

Addie, Hugh, Della and Brian are fun characters, each carefully drawn and with plenty of difficult back-story; their meetings and interactions sufficiently awkward and serendipitous at once to be credible, each not seeking out what lands with them. Addie, in particular, struck a chord; a lonely woman of 38, professionally successful but with a string of terrible men in her wake, seeking companionship from a rescue dog and salvation in the strong arms of the sea. Her sister Della seems to have it all – the happy family life, the outgoing character, the interesting wardrobe choices; and yet Della is obviously melancholy herself.

The novel is very set in its time; the 2008 US federal election is a constant theme and I fear the novel will date because of this. Nevertheless, Brian’s American-ness is strong and well-conveyed; the conflict between his desire to be more than American, more than Obama v McCain, Gore v Bush, and his Irish cousins’ reluctance to let him claim any Irishness is unexpected and simmers for quite some time.

Part of the beauty of this novel is that it doesn’t really have a plot; it has some people and some circumstances and the author sits back and stirs the pot every now and again but mostly just lets the characters interact.

Additional information:
Copy provided by the publisher in return for an honest review.
Publisher: Sphere, 400 pages (paperback)
Pre-order This Is How It Ends from Amazon*
* this is an affiliate link – I will be paid a small percentage of your purchase price if you use this link, which goes towards give-aways and site hosting

The Great Gatsby – F. Scott Fitzgerald – 7/10

“So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past.”

I’m sure you all know the story, but just in case I didn’t give enough away in my spoiler-tastic Part 1 and Part 2, here goes (TRULY SPOILER-TASTIC): Nick (not very rich) moves into a house in West Egg, discovers he has unhappily married friends Tom and Daisy in East Egg and glamorous neighbour Gatsby. Gatsby loves Daisy and has built up a sham fortune and persona to win her back. Tom is dabbling on the side with the garage owner’s wife so you’d think that Daisy would have no problem leaving him. But no, the big showdown arrives and the men descend into “she loves me more” without really consulting Daisy. Daisy kills Tom’s bit on the side on the way home (we think by accident), and Tom manages to convince the BOTS’s husband that Gatsby did it, so BOTS’s husband goes mental and shoots Gatsby and himself. And Tom and Daisy move away to fight another day.

(END OF SPOILERS)

The writing at the start of this book was so beautiful, so pin-point precise about characters with such economy of words, and then it all just descends into a pit of ridiculousness. To quote the Physicist:

“It’s just one of those Great American Novels that isn’t about anything, just everybody running around being ridiculous”

which is a little harsh, but on reflection quite true.

The first 3/4 is all about the characters and their flaws; Nick is ambivalent and has no courage, Gatsby has built a fantasy world in which Daisy will run into his arms, Tom’s just a *insert expletive here* (he’s really not a nice man!). I had such high hopes for Daisy – there was such potential for a dramatic suicide and a denouement in which the men realised their failings and resolved to do better.

The car accident and all that followed – it felt to me like FSF didn’t know how to finish his novel, like he’d crafted this masterpiece with exquisite character development, and then suddenly the publishers rang up and asked “hey, where’s my book?” and he had to quickly finish it and send it off. TNLRC tells me that this is unforgivable criticism of Mr FSF and that the sudden pointless ending is the grief of the Twenties in stunning writing*.

I feel like I used up all my happy, clever, articulate points on this book in the first two posts for the read-along, so… go read those.

I’m glad I’ve read it, but I doubt I’ll be re-reading it.

*she didn’t use exactly those words but that was the general idea

Additional info:
This  copy was a free eBook from Project Gutenberg Australia.
Order The Great Gatsby (Penguin Modern Classics) from Amazon*
* this is an affiliate link – I will be paid a small percentage of your purchase price if you use this link, which goes towards give-aways and site hosting costs.
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 547 other followers